- Despite having one of the most ethnically diverse workforces in the public sector, there are long-standing race inequalities issues in the NHS workforce, including a lack of ethnic minority representation at senior levels, ethnic minority staff being much more likely to report they have experienced discrimination at work than white staff, and fewer ethnic minority staff reporting their trust offers equal opportunities for career progression.
- Our research explored how three NHS provider organisations have sought to address workforce race inequalities and develop positive and inclusive working environments.
- The three case studies were beginning to address race inequalities and inclusion by introducing interventions to make it safer to talk about race‑related issues and interventions to enable development and career progression for ethnic minority staff.
- This type of cultural change was complex, multi-faceted and took time, but staff at each site described how the interventions and the focus on race inequalities and inclusion had started to change their working environments for the better.
- Drawing on the experiences and reflections of those involved in addressing race inequalities and inclusion in the three case studies, we offer a few key learning points and questions to encourage others to reflect their own organisation’s approaches to working on race equality and inclusion.
- We hope this report will help readers in NHS organisations as they design or implement their own local approaches to creating fairer workplaces.
- We want this report to provoke conversations about the structural and personal aspects of race inequality, and to serve as the starting point for organisations’ own deeper explorations of how they are thinking about it and working on it.
Our research, which was carried out before the Covid-19 pandemic, looked at how three NHS case studies have sought to address workforce race inequalities and develop positive and inclusive working environments. We have focused on the personal accounts and recollections of members of staff. This helped us to understand the reality and complexity of culture change.
We selected three NHS trusts where there are promising signs of positive change in terms of race inequalities and inclusion: Bradford District Care NHS Foundation Trust, Calderdale and Huddersfield NHS Foundation Trust and East London NHS Foundation Trust. In each trust, we interviewed a range of individuals, including:
- members of staff (a combination of those directly involved in race equality work and those not)
- Freedom to Speak Up Guardians
- a local trade union representative
- an organisation development manager
- equality, diversity and inclusion managers or leads
- board members (typically the chief executive and director of human resources)
- any relevant external stakeholders.
A combination of face-to-face and telephone interviews were carried out between September and November 2019. We asked participants to give their reflections on the current culture within their organisation; the specific actions that have been taken to address equality, diversity and inclusion; and what they had learnt from the experience.
All three case studies implemented similar interventions aimed at addressing race inequalities and inclusion, including:
- establishing staff networks
- ensuring psychologically safe routes for raising concerns (specifically by appointing Freedom to Speak Up Guardians)
- enabling staff development and career progression.
In combination, these interventions could support ethnic minority staff in feeling their organisations were committing to making positive changes. People told us what had changed for them personally and how they could see a shift taking place around them, with increased awareness about the challenges affecting ethnic minority staff in the workplace. More qualitative data on staff experience would offer essential indications of how change is felt.
The implementation of these interventions was largely perceived as beneficial, however we observed there was potential for some staff to react negatively to them. The interventions made it safer to talk about race, but this inevitably raised some ugly truths about behaviours between colleagues. Leaders at all levels play an important role in supporting and resourcing race equality and inclusion initiatives and addressing resistance and issues as and when they occur.
It was clear from the case study sites that everyone has a role to play in an organisation’s race equality and inclusion effort – through leadership, participation or allyship. If making workplaces more inclusive really is everyone’s responsibility, then leaders need to think about how the design and implementation of strategies or interventions model the principles of inclusion. Leadership for race equality and inclusion is an ongoing activity that creates an emotional burden. Leaders may need support, for example through peer networks or supervision.
Key learnings to consider
Although each organisation’s approach to addressing race inequalities and inclusion will be defined and designed locally depending on the circumstances, the case studies offer some key learning points for the rest of the sector to consider.
There are no magic solutions to an age-old issue. The experiences in the three NHS organisations reflects the reality of working towards race equality: to date, it has not been easy, quick or straightforward.
- Approaches to race equality and inclusion are not ‘one size fits all’. There is a lack of proven interventions and it is down to individuals and organisations making a concerted effort at a local level to iterate the approach that ‘works’ for them.
- Addressing inequalities and inclusion needs to be an ongoing, ‘moment-by-moment’ activity that engages with and responds to people’s lived experiences.
Briefly: i am a retired NHS Mental Health Clinical skills tutor. I am currently supporting a colleague that has a lead role in Diversity and Inclusion. I would be grateful if you would let me have access to your work, as i was interested in your comments.
As senior managers (Over the years) we have both seen how easy it is to produce masses of data and glossy reports-which produces no positive action!! This time we are determined to make a difference-so anything you feel you can offer in terms of advice or research etc would be most welcome.
I have experienced many forms of discrimination throughout my career. I have applied for many promotions but never seem to be the right candidate.
It progresses more deeply when it is your turn for promotion they then decide to use forms of nit picking and constant criticism to give them reason to why you can not be selected. This in order to give the promotions and praise to the staff members they like and want to have status and diversity within there job role.
I have been verbally abused and had to go through a traumatic grievance procedure but the system put in place seems to try and protect the senior managers that are bullying. The trust champions have little powers and the union reps are reluctant to actually deal with the problem as it would mean them potential ally loosing there job.
Policies and accountability needs to be the way to stop the systemic discrimination within the nhs system. Also having more BAME members in positions to actually make changes.
As a mature staff nurse I feel discriminated against. I have 21 years of experience but yet am not able to be accepted when I went for band 6 interview several times. The younger newly qualified nurse get it faster. I belief there should be way to support experience mature nurses. you feel humiliated see all the people you mentor and supported getting it and you are not able to get it.
I love working with ELFT because of the opportunity they give staff but as a mature and experience nurse I didn't think their is much support in area of progressing your carrier I feel stuck. But I have seen other mature people from different race moving up the ladder
Hi Celia - thanks for your comment. This sounds like a really interesting intervention. If you're willing to, please email me via firstname.lastname@example.org as it'd be good to hear more about how this approach worked at your trust. Shilpa
One essential ED&I intervention that is absent from your review is the elimination of systematic discriminatory practices and policies through the evaluation and analysis of practices. This is done through equality impact assessment, benchmarking and full review of people/HR processes.
This is a process fundamental in establishing strong ED&I foundations and usually shunned by Trusts as the it isn't a visible, high profile intervention. Ironically without this work, Trusts will continue to experience racism because establishing staff groups, and speaking groups without a proper foundation to support them means they have a short shelf life.
I co-wrote a paper which was published in the AMTCP book series in June 2018. I outline all the issues of inequality in the NHS and suggest health literacy as a solution. Now is the time for action, not more report writing, I did all my research for the paper at King's, the information on inequalities for staff and patients has been around for a long time. But nobody seems to want to do anything about, it, other than write more reports! I do apologise for my tone, I'm just frustrated that no one is paying attention to the blinding obvious! Feel free to contact me about my work, if anyone is interested in more details.
Thank you for your comment. I am sorry to hear about your experiences. If it's helpful, please take a look at these sources of support: https://www.kingsfund.org.uk/projects/inequalities-inclusion-nhs-provid…
I would have loved to contribute to your work; as I am a senior member of nursing staff from the Ethnic minority who has suffered and continues to suffer within my team.
I agree we have the support to speak to our Line Manager and HR staff. Despite all this, I would like to say if the bully is someone at a higher level than you, like a Consultant Surgeon, your voice is never heard. The Trust does their best to keep the situation calm but will not address it firmly to the Consultant Surgeon. I am happy to talk if you are looking for more reports.
Prefer to remain anonymous for my security, as I am not sure if my comments will be made public.