Developing a culture of compassionate care

This content relates to the following topics:

Care, compassion, competence, communication, courage and commitment. These are the six Cs set out in the Chief Nursing Officer's recent consultation paper Developing the culture of compassionate care: Creating a new vision and strategy for nurses, midwives and care-givers.

The paper aims to 'set out a shared purpose' for staff in those roles, with six key areas for action. But why do we need a new vision for nurses, midwives and care-givers? And what difference will this vision make?

Two years ago, the Prime Minister's Commission on the Future of Nursing and Midwifery in England published a vision for nursing and midwifery called Front Line Care, which seems to have disappeared into oblivion. And only five months ago, the Nursing and Care Quality Forum (NCQF) published a letter to this Prime Minister with perfectly sensible recommendations about what to do about nursing. The Chief Nursing Officer is working with the NCQF but the vision does not refer to its recommendations.

The new vision differs a little from the earlier ones. It focuses much more on nurses' and midwives' roles in prevention and health promotion and on ‘making every contact count'. Strangely, given the focus on care and compassion, it does not mention nurses' contribution to caring for the half a million people who die each year, fifty percent of whom die in hospital. The NCQF has been explicit that quality of care is linked to staffing, skill mix, and nurses and midwives being able to spend time with individual patients. This new paper acknowledges that lack of time, lack of support, long shift patterns and expanded roles contribute to the apparent lack of empathy in some areas of nursing. However it defers tackling these challenges until the next stage of the work, without saying when that will start or how many stages will follow.

Fundamentally however, what is troubling about this vision and the others is the attempt to create an independent vision for nursing, midwifery, and care-giving separate from the rest of the health care system. All the visions acknowledge that nurses and midwives are members of a 'wider team', but they are not co-produced with health professionals and managers or with patients and relatives. Of course the professions have their own cultures, their own bodies of knowledge and practice, and their own hierarchies and ways of working. And values and behaviours in nursing and midwifery are critically important. But nurses, midwives and care-givers look after patients in the context of organisations, not in isolation. It's simply not possible to deliver reliable, compassionate care 24/7 unless the system as a whole makes it a priority and the most powerful people in the system actively demonstrate their commitment to the values and behaviours that support caring. Read the excellent 'Preventing Abuse and Neglect in Institutional Care of Older Adults' (PANICOA) Dignity in Care report, or the hundreds of pages of testimony to the Mid-Staffordshire Inquiry, or the report of the investigation into Winterbourne View and then ask yourself how much change nurses, midwives and care assistants can achieve on their own, and without the active support of others in the system.

In the USA a growing number of organisations are appointing Board-level Chief Experience Officers. In the absence of such a role on the NHS Commissioning Board, I would like to see a vision for care for patients and their relatives, jointly written by the Chief Executive, the Chief Nursing Officer, the Chief Medical Officer, the Director of Patient Experience and the Chief Financial Officer and signed off by the whole Board. The Board, by virtue of its position, will shape the wider culture of care and working practices across the whole of the health care system. How good it would be to see those at the top modelling the collaborative leadership and close working that patients and relatives need between the nurses, doctors, therapists, managers and support staff who look after them.

Comments

Jane McLean

Position
Head of Leadership,
Organisation
Lincolnshire Foundation Partnership Trust
Comment date
24 January 2014
I too have felt inspired by the discussion above to add to this debate.

I am a social worker "by trade" having practiced in mental health for the last 20 years. In the last 7 years I have been a service manager for mental health services. I am about to embark upon a new role in the Trust I work for, as Head of Leadership.

I embarked upon my MSC in Recovery and Social Inclusion in Mental Health in 2010 and am currently completing my dissertation on a critical review of leadership in mental health services following the Francis report. Looking at what this means for organisations and cultures and whether, the wider powerful socio/political structures, in which the NHS operate, directly conflict with the ability to provide a compassionate and value based leadership approach.

I was specifically interested in Paul Crawford's work around this and given my MSC is with Nottingham University, will be contacting him to discuss this further.

However, I was heartened by the stealthy and resiliant reply of Natalie Smith, 3rd year student; as the conclusions that I am drawing are that, there are powerful structures at play which directly mitigate against the conditions required to put into place the compassionate based leadership required of the NHS.

However, I fundamentally believe that each person has the responsibility to remember and practice the values associated with compassion; and if we all practiced these behaviours, then the leadership debate would move forward significantly; perhaps making the structural and whole scale process changes required, seem less insurmountable by a united, resiliant and caring work force. (sounds like the formation of a conclusion here!)

Idealistic? maybe, but what is our alternative, to turn a blind eye? surely our personal integrity cannot allow us to do this

Natalie Smith

Position
Student Nurse, 3rd Year.,
Organisation
University of Huddersfield
Comment date
09 April 2013
I began my Nurse training three years ago with the goal of being the best care provider I could be. Being there for my patients when they are most vulnerable, listening to them when no-one else can, supporting them through every hurdle they face, and providing the most compassionate care possible. This vision has not changed, and amongst most nurses, midwives and care givers, whomever, this continues to be their vision also. We cannot continue to blame poor systems, resources, financial constraints etc on the lack of compassion. It should not matter whether you have 20 seconds to spend with a patient or 20 minutes. You can still be compassionate. The Francis Report recently highlighted so many areas that we as care providers are lacking, as we continue to fail our patients. Reforms will not change nursing, just as we witness policies having a minimal impact on practice. There will always be room for improvement. It is up to the individuals to make the change.

Paul Crawford

Position
Professor,
Organisation
The University of Nottingham
Comment date
09 February 2013
I think the 6 C's was a start-up for debate but needed to foreground much more strongly the context in which our nurses are operating and how environments, processes and so on need to be designed compassionately to give professionals a chance to give their best care. As we have seen with the Francis Report there is an urgent need to focus on systemic and structural level problems with the NHS rather than those of agency alone. The latter has dominated debates in the media with the framing of cruel nurses and doctors. Now we need a deeper recognition of the need for evidence-based management of our NHS.

In light of the Francis Report you may wish to read the following and any comments that have accrued.

Crawford, P. (2013) The NHS and the true meaning of compassion. Health & Social Care Reform. GovToday. Editor’s Feature. http://www.hscreformseries.co.uk/leadership/14747-the-nhs-and-the-true-meaning-of-compassion. Also got a mention at The Guardian:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/healthcare-network/2013/feb/08/today-in-healthcare-8-february

Paul

Linnette King

Position
University Lecturer,
Organisation
University of Brighton
Comment date
04 February 2013
I have found the advice and promotion of the six C's promoted by the Chief Nursing Officer rang a familiar 'knell' and have waited to see if anyone would confirm this. Strong similarity is noted with Simone Roach, 1992, who stated that caring is the human mode of caring. She set out the six C's as attributes of caring to aid in indentifying the specific caring behaviours that a nurse engages in when providing care for a patient; compassion, competence, confidence, conscience, commitment, and comportment. These were proposed as goals that a nurse could strive towards when providing care, a basis that should lead to profound and virtuous care that would be expected of a professional nurse.

Chris Manning

Position
Director; Ret'd GP,
Organisation
UPstream Healthcare Ltd.
Comment date
23 January 2013
Whistle-blowing can be considered as one of the crucial elements of 'bio-feedback' required to ensure healthy, thriving and oxygenated ecosystems - in this case, healthcare. We will know we are getting somewhere when every comment about quality of delivery and receipt of service are valued and encouraged; when fear, back-covering, gaming, intimidation and constructive activities to diminish people's commitment, endeavour and values are mitigated. When aspirant and caring people are not brutalised in the first please; the majority of those who go into health, social care and education do not do so to deliver mediocrity - they have it thrust upon them. When the head of the NHS says that the service for which he is directly responsible is neither fit nor safe for some of the most vulnerable people using it and that they need to placed in the community (all well and good where appropriately discussed and decided) then we know the organisation is simply not in the right hands - even if they are well washed. Who dares - cares?

Robert Gebka

Position
Director Dorset Mindfulness Centre/ NHS co lead Mindful SPACE for Staff Wellbeing programme,
Organisation
Dorset Mindfulness Centre
Comment date
18 January 2013
I was inspired to come across your website and wanted to share with you some of my work involving Mindfulness in Healthcare.

I am exploring connecting with other like minded organisations so as to promote this beneficial work.

Please allow me to introduce myself, my name is Robert Gebka, I am the director of the Dorset Mindfulness Centre dorset-mindfulness.co.uk I also work part time within mental health for the NHS dorsethealthcare.nhs.uk

Together with a colleague, I recently initiated and now co lead the Mindful SPACE: Mindfulness for Staff Wellbeing programme.

This new and innovative programme contributes to the development of a culture of compassionate care and the 6 Cs as well as supporting staff via the self management/self care approach in their efforts to regain as well as maintain a sense of work-life balance and mental wellbeing.

We had two staff NHS mindfulness meetings last year to explore this idea and had our first Mindful SPACE Bournemouth group last night with 16 NHS staff attending.

On 16 January I also presented, via the Dorset Mindfulness Centre, Mindfulness in Healthcare: Bringing Intention, Attention and Reflection to Healthcare workshop at Bournemouth University.

We had approximately 25 Occupational Therapy students attending. The purpose of the workshop was to inspire and support healthcare students in their own wellbeing and to contribute to the 6 Cs of Care, Compassion, Competence, Communication, Courage and Commitment in this way enhancing therapeutic engagement skills and self efficacy through mindfulness.

I am just curious if you are interested in this work and if you would be happy to establish contact.

Many thanks for your time

Robert

John Barnes

Position
consultant psychiatrist,
Organisation
an NHS trust
Comment date
15 January 2013
This is a very good thread of conversation about compassionate care with several interesting contributions which look worthwhile following up. Everybody Matters, the The "deep change programme" that Andy Bradley has been involved with seems particularly interesting as it is actually trying to foster compassion in staff in a part of a trust where leaders have committed themselves to "creating and sustaining consistent compassion".
I like that he has been accused of naivety as that has happened to me too on occasion!
I wish to add to this thread the concept of "Intelligent Kindness" developed by John Ballatt and Penelope Campling who wrote a book of the same name recently in 2011 concerning the need for reform of the culture in the NHS.
A 5 page sample chapter from the book is easily downloadable for free at;
rcpsych.ac.uk/files/samplechapter/IntelligentKindnessSC.pdf) .
The authors are a manager/commissioner and a psychiatrist and I believe the book to be a tremendously helpful resource in understanding, from several perspectives, the right conditions for Kindness (and its opposite)to flourish in the NHS.

barbara smith

Position
Lecturer,
Organisation
Coventry University
Comment date
10 December 2012
I have been fighting for the importance of caring and compassion in nursing since 2000, it is a shame that it has taken 12 years for the nursing profession to wake up to just how important these things are.

Josephine Smit…

Position
Analyst,
Organisation
Religious Order
Comment date
16 November 2012
After reading just a little of the contributions listed;
This has inspired me to add a small contribution myself.
The Health Service whether NHS or private. No comment.
At a Conference several years ago, the Voluntary sector support was
not discussed in enough depth.
This support has proved to be a fallacy.
Facing situations where " unmet need" , falling standards.
Basic Humanity & common sense day to day general care,
These are the important things to be thinking about.
I will give an example:
A patient, having had a serious operation within the last year,
When admitted vomited blood,
then sent home to totally inadequate support.
Cause taking her medication as instructed, but not with food,
as she was struggling to manage.
Their answer, pain management.
Also she was sent home very late considering the time of year,
to an unheated house.
When readmitted to hospital she had pneumonia.
You need very few qualifications to appreciate & evaluate
such cases. Just Respect; understanding, Compassion of course,
Nursing is & always has been a vocation; To become a good nurse
or Doctor these Qualities are essential & always have been.
To be continued.

Paul Crawford

Position
Professor of Health Humanities,
Organisation
The University of Nottingham/ Institute of Mental Health
Comment date
02 November 2012
Dear friends, you may wish to read the recent piece I did for Public Servant journal. This refers to issues around health humanities and compassionate design of health care. There is a link below the reference to the online version.
Crawford (2012) Humanity: A precious resource. Public Servant, October: 43
publicservice.co.uk/feature_story.asp?id=21287

Add your comment